In the film “Race: The
Power of an Illusion, Episode 1”, microbiologist
Pilar Osorio stated, There’s as much or more diversity and genetic difference
within any racial group as there is between people of different racial groups.
Pilar Osorio’s statement is proven because throughout many years scientists
have studied race and discovered that people within racial groups have more
differences than those who are part of another racial group. Human beings have
a long history of searching for race differences and because of it they have
made people in a way believe that we have to have races to distinguish each other
and be part of a certain group that has the same similarities as we do. The scientist Linnaeus created four different types of races that inhabited the earth. The races were: Americanus, Asiatics, Africanous, and the superior race according to him the Europaenus. Many
people believe that race is biological constructed because they believe that is
constructed based on genetics and that it has a long history since our ancestors
and it hasn’t changed at all since then.
Race was invented to categorize similar concepts between groups. Race is also negative and very harmful but the film stated that we can unmake it since we have created it. Race has been a problem for the longest time, evolving overtime and when segregation took place whites were on top of everyone else because of their skin color. African Americans have always been the minority and many people think they are inferior because of they are different in skin color. Hoffman conducted that African Americans were in danger of extinction because it was parted in their blood. In the 1930s Negro athletes were judged and criticized a lot because they were great at every sport they played. Many people believed that they were really good at the sports they practiced because of their genes and their body type. Scientists discovered that genetic ancestry does not have anything to do with athlete capacity and that there is no physical features for Negros that makes them special, instead everything has to do with our environment, and how we have evolved over time. In the film a study was conducted among students to identify if there were differences among their racial groups. There were students from different backgrounds, among them were White, African Americans, Hispanics, and Asians. Prior to the study students with the same racial groups thought that they were going to have the most similarities than the other racial groups. The students were tested based on their DNA and the results showed evidence that there is a huge difference among people of the same racial groups than the ones of other groups, proving Osorio's statement. Also a geneticist stated that 85% of genetic differences were among local populations and it demonstrated how race is socially constructed.
I have always
considered myself Hispanic to be more specific Mexican. I usually think of
myself as a regular sometimes weird girl that gets along with pretty much
everybody that talks to me. Sometimes people think that I am from the Middle
East and talk to me in their language, many of them get offended because they
think that am ignoring them or that I don’t want to embrace their culture. They
get very surprised when I tell them that I am Mexican and not from their
countries, yet I have learned to live with that because I myself also misjudge
people when I think that they are Mexicans and they are not. The evidence
provided in the film does not affect the way I think of myself because I believe
that everyone is equal and that everyone should be treated with respect no
matter their cultural and racial background.Race was invented to categorize similar concepts between groups. Race is also negative and very harmful but the film stated that we can unmake it since we have created it. Race has been a problem for the longest time, evolving overtime and when segregation took place whites were on top of everyone else because of their skin color. African Americans have always been the minority and many people think they are inferior because of they are different in skin color. Hoffman conducted that African Americans were in danger of extinction because it was parted in their blood. In the 1930s Negro athletes were judged and criticized a lot because they were great at every sport they played. Many people believed that they were really good at the sports they practiced because of their genes and their body type. Scientists discovered that genetic ancestry does not have anything to do with athlete capacity and that there is no physical features for Negros that makes them special, instead everything has to do with our environment, and how we have evolved over time. In the film a study was conducted among students to identify if there were differences among their racial groups. There were students from different backgrounds, among them were White, African Americans, Hispanics, and Asians. Prior to the study students with the same racial groups thought that they were going to have the most similarities than the other racial groups. The students were tested based on their DNA and the results showed evidence that there is a huge difference among people of the same racial groups than the ones of other groups, proving Osorio's statement. Also a geneticist stated that 85% of genetic differences were among local populations and it demonstrated how race is socially constructed.
Race still persist even though scientists are unable find a genetic basis for social ideas of racial differences because it has made everything easier for the people in power. The people in power in the U.S are usually white males who make laws that benefits them and the people the are like them. Having races also has helped out the government, for example in the census so they know who belongs were according to their ethnicity. Having different races will always be part of our lives because the ones that benefit from being part of the superior race have an easier life and they don't want anything to change. Of course lets not forget that the superior race are the people in power who control everyone else.
These are interesting reflections. I'd like for you to go back and edit to make your points a bit clearer.
ReplyDeletePlease also go back in and create hyperlinks instead of having the links in your text.
Here is a youtube video that explains how to create a hyperlink in blogger: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-igN-wxeIE
Great job describing the film, I feel that you summarized it nicely in your second paragraph. A couple of things that I would suggest is use evidence from the film to back up your points; it would help create a clearer understanding of what you are trying to convey. Also, I think you could probably expand a little more on how it made you view yourself. Overall, I really enjoyed reading your response.
ReplyDeleteHello, good job on your blog it was really interesting to read. I liked your first paragraph because you went straight to the point and went to the problem of race not being biological or having a certain gene that characterizes one race from another. In addition I like the picture you used because in your blog you talk about African Americans being a minority and their athletic ability and I feel like that picture with an African American and a White person holding hands suggest a type of peace between them. Some suggestions I have is to go back to your second paragraph and just review it to make some of your sentences flow better to make your ideas clearer. In addition just create hyperlinks for your links.
ReplyDeleteHi Monica,
ReplyDeleteI really admired the way that you incorporated Pilar Ossorio's statement because this gave your audience the ability to really understand what Ossorio meant and to understand the purpose of your post.
I also found that you incorporated a lot of interesting and important history behind racial inequalities. I found that the history that you gave really supported your points. However, I agree with Mirian's comment; I would like to read more about your own racial identity and how this video affected your view of yourself.
I would like to read more about your racial identity because I was also very intrigued by your description about the way that others accidentally categorize you as a different race. I was intrigued by your description of these occurrences because I too am Hispanic and am frequently classified as a White female.
Overall, I enjoyed your post and could relate to your points, but you may need to incorporate your links into your paragraphs.